Skip to content

How to tell an honest software ranking: 6 questions you can answer from the page itself

Criteria, how the score is calculated, labels on paid placements, the reasoning behind an "editor's choice," review verification and the site's owner: six things to check before you trust a ranking.

Software rankings share one weakness: readers rarely know where the order comes from. Before you trust "the best invoicing software," ask six questions whose answers can be found on the page.

1. Are the criteria clear?

It should be visible what earns a program points. A ranking without criteria is the author's opinion.

2. Does it explain how the score is calculated?

A list of criteria is not enough. A good ranking tells you about the weights, the sources and the date of the data.

3. Are paid placements labeled?

If the site earns money from a position in the ranking, it should show this next to the score, not in the terms and conditions.

4. Does the "editor's choice" have a justification?

Simply stating "we recommend" is not a justification. Look for data, tests or a description of how the product was checked.

5. Are reviews verified, and can the vendor remove them?

Reviews that nobody checks, and a vendor with the right to hide criticism, give a picture better than reality.

6. Who runs the site?

A ranking run by the vendor of one of the products being rated doesn't have to be bad, but it should make that clear.

What next

We ask internet users the same questions in our ranking: rate a site you know and see how we calculate the score. We write about where we may have our own interest in the article on transparency.